Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza

Discover authentic Argentine and New York-style pizza at Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza, located at 106 Main St, Mineola, NY. Enjoy delicious empanadas, grandma pie, rigatoni alla vodka, and more. Call +1 516-294-2994!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza

Located at 106 Main St, Mineola, NY, Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza serves a unique blend of traditional New York-style pizza and Argentinian influences. This cozy pizzeria stands out not just for its mouthwatering pies but also for its warm atmosphere that invites conversation and connection. Patrons rave about the crispy crusts and the variety that sets Mamma Gina’s apart. With a menu boasting everything from Grandma pies to empanadas, every bite tells a story of culinary heritage. Whether popping by for a quick lunch or gathering with friends for dinner, this spot guarantees satisfaction and a taste of home baked into each dish.

Mamma Gina's offers a diverse menu that caters to all pizza lovers. The large cheese pizza remains a staple favorite, while specialty pizzas such as the Buffalo Chicken Crispy Pizza delight adventurous eaters. Customers can also indulge in a variety of appetizers, ensuring a complete dining experience. The popular empanadas bring a taste of Argentina to this New York gem, making it a must-try for those curious about this flavorful dish.

The establishment accommodates families and groups comfortably. With bustling peak hours, the ambiance remains friendly, always buzzing with cheerful chatter and the comforting aroma of fresh ingredients.

Regular visitors often recommend the additional garlic knots to complement your meal—a perfect starter or side to your pizza. Mamma Gina's prides itself on a commitment to freshness, optimizing their ingredients to ensure high quality.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

106 Main St, Mineola, NY 11501, United States

Phone

+1 516-294-2994

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza
Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza

Since opening its doors, Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza has carved a niche in the local dining scene. The love for pizza here transcends mere food; it's about community and sharing. The restaurant draws both locals and visitors, creating a melting pot of flavors and cultures. The pizzeria operates on the principle that great food brings people together.

The menu reflects Mamma Gina's passion for the culinary arts, merging traditional recipes with innovative twists. The Grandma pie takes center stage for its crispy bottom and generous toppings, celebrated for its homestyle taste.

Enjoying a slice might remind you of family gatherings where the focus is on sharing and enjoying good meals. Empanadas, another highlight, demonstrate the restaurant's knack for infusing Argentinian flair. Each dish promises an inviting experience, encouraging customers to explore more flavors and pairings.

Mamma Gina's operates with agility, adjusting to busy lunch times when patrons flock for a quick yet delicious meal. Regulars know that Tuesdays at noon are peak times, often requiring reservations or a bit of patience during the lunch rush.

Longer wait times on popular nights only add to the playful community chatter, as locals swap stories and share tips about the best pizza pairings while they wait. Whether it’s a casual Wednesday night or a festive Saturday evening, Mamma Gina’s always welcomes you with open arms.

Mamma Gina's Mineola Pizza

Mamma Gina's stands proudly on Main St, vibrant and inviting to all who walk by. Its exterior is bright, showcasing a faded yet charming decor that speaks of warmth and history. Outdoor seating adds a delightful layer, perfect for enjoying a meal amidst the evening air. The vibe is lively during peak times, with laughter and storytelling spilling out onto the streets. Patrons often choose to eat outdoors, savoring their meals while mingling with the friendly Mineola community. Whether dining indoors or out, Mamma Gina's atmosphere captures the essence of social dining.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday10 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-10 PM
  • Friday10 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We came here on a Sunday early evening after reading reviews and it didn't disappoint. We enjoyed a slice of regular NY style pizza, grilled rib steak, fried mozzarella sticks for appetizers, and linguine in white clam sauce. We like that it's elevated comfort food. They didn't skimp on ingredients and quality. Place is clean with a nice ambiance. Steak was smoky and juicy although I must say that it wasn't a true medium rare, which is what I ordered. But the it was flavorful. More importantly, I truly enjoyed the pizza. I will definitely be back for more pizza.

H
Hsu J.

Stumbled upon this gem on accident and I'm so glad I came in to try it out. Amazing service with a smile, I've never felt more welcomed in a pizzeria. Perfect 5 stars. Restaurant is beautiful and the food is delicious, the pizza crust and undercarriage is super crispppyyyy! Will definitely be coming back soon to try the Argentinian options. I love the hospitality and the owner is so genuine and kind. Its so rare nowadays where the owner is engaged with his customers and makes them feel like old friends. Dave Portnoy would love this place, solid solid 9.1

Y
YabbadabbadoO

If you're looking for the best Argentine food on Long Island, this is it. The asado here is absolutely authentic! and served with that classic chimichurri that instantly transports you to Buenos Aires. Every bite tastes like it came straight off a backyard parrilla in Argentina. The cool part is you can choose: take out pizza NY style, Italian food, or Argentine food!

m
melissa s.

This is the place for Argentine style pizza! Staff is very friendly. Food is always delicious! Order their Empanada's as well!

C
Christian

I just moved here in this neighborhood from Queens. I called this pizza parlor by mistake. The guy on the phone told me this was the best pizza parlor in the city and he was absolutely correct. :-) This was the best restaurant I have ever ate from for Italian food hands-down if I could give this 100 stars I would give this 100 stars. I 1000% recommend eating here if you're looking for good Italian food nothing tasted old or fake or disgusting or unseasoned. I ordered the chicken Parmesan dinner and I devoured the entire thing it was so flavorful and crispy and you could tell they used real ingredients. It didn't taste old or soggy or disgusting like it does in Queens. This is the best little Italian spot that I have ever ate from. This is definitely going to be my regular from now on guy on the phone wasn't kidding, this is the best pizza parlor I have ever ate from the pizza was crispy, saucy, and cheesy. The pepperoni was fresh. Everything that I ordered was very enjoyable and delicious me and my family really enjoyed this place. We highly recommend eating from here. The french fries were crispy. The chicken tenders were crispy. Everything was seasoned and delicious. I highly recommend stopping here if you live in Long Island this is really good thank you so much. God bless and have an amazing day. Thank you. Best restaurant ever five star review.

l
lisichka f.

Amazing amazing place! Good local jojnt. Love the pizza. So unique with the flavors and people working there are fantastic. Just one of the many good pizza joints in Mineola!

D
Deep S.